Routledge Handbooks in Applied Ethics The Routledge Handbook of Philosophy and Poverty
It is undeniable that poverty is a serious problem today. The rate of absolute poverty in the world has been decreasing since 1990. However, relative poverty is getting worse in many countries. The causes are not only economic, such as wage inequality; political oppression, discrimination and climate change also play an important role in relative poverty. In other words, poverty is inextricably linked to the problems of today’s world.
The Routledge Handbook of Philosophy and Poverty is a collection of essays covering a wide range of philosophical approaches to poverty. Philosophical discussions of poverty have taken many forms in recent years. Philosophy allows us to approach the fundamental questions about poverty in a conceptually and theoretically sophisticated manner. What is poverty? How can we measure poverty? What is morally wrong about poverty? What duties and responsibilities do we have to address the problems of poverty? These are the philosophical questions about poverty. Failure to address these questions may undermine the relevance and stability of (re)distributional policies.
This book is distinguished by its comprehensive and in-depth collection of contemporary, historical, and applied philosophical approaches to poverty. Particularly noteworthy is the coverage of non-Western philosophical approaches to poverty (PART III). The authors are experts in their respective topics and fields, making this anthology an excellent introduction to a wide variety of philosophical approaches to poverty.
I () contributed to Chapter 25, “Autonomy and Poverty,” of PART IV “Key Ethical Concepts and Poverty.” Autonomy refers not only to the mere possession of one’s own capacities, but also to the exercise of those capacities without being subject to external forces such as manipulation. There is a deep connection between autonomy and poverty. Importantly, the dilemma of this connection has been discussed in political philosophy and ethics in recent years. This is based on the concern that while eliminating poverty (and its causes) is seen as promoting autonomy, it may also lead to a situation in which certain people become “dependent” on the means (typically social welfare policies) to eliminate poverty. In other words, anti-poverty policies designed to promote autonomy may undermine autonomy, which is a dilemma.
In this chapter, I discuss representative theories in political philosophy that confront the autonomy-poverty dilemma, such as luck egalitarianism, relational egalitarianism, and ethical approaches to care and relational autonomy that depart from standard approaches in political philosophy, and show that each has problems to overcome. I hope you will read and critically examine my essay. This book is an anthology of essays worthy of such careful consideration.
(Written by INOUE Akira, Professor, Graduate School of Arts and Sciences / 2024)
Table of Contents
Gottfried Schweiger and Clemens Sedmak
Section 1: Concepts, theories and philosophical aspects of poverty research
1. Monetary poverty
Clemens Sedmak
2. Capabilities and Poverty
Yuko Kamishima
3. Social Exclusion and Poverty
Gideon Calder
4. Philosophy, poverty, and inequality: normative and applied reflections
Katarina Pitasse Fragoso and Marie-Pier Lemay
5. Epistemology, philosophy of science, and poverty research
Clemens Sedmak
6. Ethics in poverty research
Ann Mitchell
Section 2: Poverty in the history of philosophy and philosophical traditions
7. Poverty in Graeco-Roman Philosophy
Lucia Cecchet
8. Poverty in Medieval Philosophy
Hans Kraml
9. Poverty in modern European philosophy from the Renaissance to the 20th century
Alessandro Pinzani
10. Utilitarianism and Poverty
Brian Berkey
11. Liberalism and poverty
Borja Barragué
12. Critical Theory and Poverty
David Ingram
13. Marx and Poverty
Arash Abazari
14. Feminist Philosophy and Poverty
Christine M. Koggel
Section 3: Poverty in non-Western philosophical thought
15. Decolonial Approaches to Poverty
Robin Dunford
16. Poverty and African Social and Political Thought
Uchenna Okeja
17. Poverty in Chinese Philosophy
Jifen Li
18. Poverty in Indian Philosophy through the lens of the Religious and the Secular: An Exposition
Shashi Motilal
19. Poverty in Islamic Philosophy
Muqtedar Khan and Mohammed Ayub Khan
20. Poverty and Latin American Philosophy
Eduardo Mendieta
Section 4: Key ethical concepts and poverty
21. Duties and Poverty
Stephanie Collins
22. Poverty and human dignity: What is the relationship?
H.P.P. (Hennie) Lötter
23. Entitled to A Good Life Without Qualification: How Poverty Wrongs Those Experiencing It
Cindy Holder
24. Recognition and Poverty
Monica Mookherjee
25. Autonomy and Poverty
26. Empowerment and Poverty
Jay Drydyk, Diana Velasco, and Kerry O’Neill
27. Poverty and Human Rights
Anandita Mukherji and Abigail Gosselin
Section 5: Social and political issues
28. Global justice and poverty
Vincent Fang
29. Poverty and Social Justice
Valentin Beck
30. Welfare State and Poverty
Cristian Pérez Muñoz
31. Why Racialized Poverty Matters — and the Way Forward
Michael Cholbi
32. Poverty, health and justice
Sridhar Venkatapuram
33. Development Policy and Poverty
Lori Keleher
34. Climate Change and Poverty
Darrel Moellendorf
35. Migration and Poverty
Alejandra Mancilla
36. Education and Poverty
Julian Culp
37. Gender and Poverty
Susan P. Murphy
38. The Economy and Poverty
Irene Bucelli
39. Child Poverty
Gottfried Schweiger